Some supervisors lead with vision, others with collaboration, others with consistency. And then there are supervisors who lead from the center of a storm—always reacting, always scrambling, always one emergency away from unraveling. Their days are filled with urgent requests, shifting priorities, and last-minute decisions. For employees, this mode of leadership doesn’t inspire action—it disrupts it.
Yet crisis-driven leadership is not a fixed trait. It’s a solvable management problem, one that can be addressed through intentional planning, clearer communication, and systems that support steadiness rather than impulsive reaction. The issue isn’t the existence of crisis—it’s the absence of structures that keep crisis from becoming the culture.
This is a problem that can be named, understood, and changed.
Understanding the Causes Helps Us Solve Them
Supervisors rarely set out to lead through chaos. More often, they’ve fallen into reactive habits because of structural or skill-based gaps. Many crisis-driven supervisors are:
- Overextended with too many responsibilities
- Undertrained in planning and workload management
- Unclear about organizational priorities
- Rewarded for rescuing last-minute problems
- Operating without systems that support long-term thinking
These root causes are all addressable. When we understand them, we can replace panic with clarity and reaction with direction.
The Human Impact—and the Opportunity for Improvement
The consequences of reactive supervision are well known: exhaustion, lost trust, shifting expectations, and work that never lands on steady ground. But these outcomes also point directly to what needs strengthening: consistency, communication, and predictable structures. They show us where to intervene.
Employees don’t need perfection. They need planning. They need time. They need guidance that arrives before the emergency, not during it.
Crisis-mode supervision feels destabilizing, but it is one of the most fixable forms of leadership dysfunction.
Solutions for Employees
Employees cannot redesign organizational systems alone, but they can establish practices that bring stability into uncertain environments.
1. Create Predictable Structures
When supervisors can’t plan, employees can anchor their own workflow by:
- Creating weekly and monthly plans
- Tracking shifting priorities
- Building timelines backward from deadlines
- Documenting decisions and changes
These habits provide continuity, clarity, and protection.
2. Use Clarifying Questions to Bring Focus
Questions can introduce order into chaotic situations:
- “What should I deprioritize to fit this in?”
- “What’s the real deadline?”
- “Who else needs to be involved?”
This doesn’t challenge authority—it stabilizes the conversation.
3. Identify Patterns and Plan Around Them
If emergencies always happen at predictable points—month-end, event weeks, budget cycles—employees can prepare proactively with templates, buffers, and blocked time.
4. Hold Firm Boundaries
A supervisor’s urgency doesn’t have to become an employee’s lifestyle. Employees can maintain healthy boundaries by:
- Naming their bandwidth
- Offering realistic timelines
- Protecting personal time
Boundaries are not barriers—they’re stabilizers.
5. Document Consistently
In reactive environments, written records are essential to clarify expectations, track changes, and prevent miscommunication.
Solutions for Supervisors
Reactive supervision is often the result of limited tools rather than limited ability. Supervisors who want to move from crisis to clarity can adopt small, high-impact practices.
1. Establish a Planning Rhythm
Weekly check-ins with staff, monthly project reviews, and quarterly goal-setting sessions create structure that reduces surprise and panic.
2. Refine Priorities and Communicate Them Clearly
Employees cannot plan if priorities shift without explanation. Supervisors can create alignment by regularly communicating:
- What matters most
- What can wait
- What success should look like
Consistency reduces chaos.
3. Implement Workload and Task Management Systems
Simple systems—Kanban boards (a visual workflow management tool used to track tasks as they move through stages of completion. It helps individuals and teams see their work at a glance, prioritize effectively, and reduce bottlenecks), shared calendars, project timelines—help supervisors see the full picture instead of reacting to what’s loudest.
4. Transition from Last-Minute to Long-View Decision-Making
Before declaring an emergency, supervisors can ask:
- “Was this preventable?”
- “What system would have avoided this?”
- “How can we prevent this next time?”
This reflection alone begins to shift the culture.
5. Develop Emotional Steadiness
Crisis leadership requires calm, not adrenaline. Supervisors can practice:
- Pausing before redirecting staff
- Communicating expectations with clarity
- Responding, not reacting
Calm behavior is contagious—and so is chaos.
Solutions for Organizations
Reactive supervision persists when organizations lack systems that support foresight. But institutions can put structures in place that reduce crisis dependence.
1. Normalize and Train Managers in Planning
Workshops on workload management, strategic planning, and communication give supervisors the tools they need to lead with intention.
2. Incentivize Stability, Not Firefighting
If organizations reward heroic last-minute saves but ignore early planning, the cycle continues. Recognition should emphasize:
- Proactive problem-solving
- Meeting timelines
- Reducing emergencies
3. Set Clear Institutional Priorities
Supervisors can’t plan when the organization itself is unclear. Transparent, consistently communicated priorities give teams the direction they need.
4. Build Sustainable Workflows
Shared calendars, standard operating procedures, cross-training, and centralized information systems decrease the odds of last-minute crises.
5. Ensure Supervisors Have Reasonable Spans of Control
Supervisors managing too many people or projects are more likely to operate in crisis mode. Right-sized workloads support right-sized leadership.
Resources for Supervisors Who Want to Change
Supervisors who recognize themselves in this pattern might find guidance in:
- Is Your Leadership Too Reactive? (Harvard Business Review)
https://hbr.org/2025/08/is-your-leadership-too-reactive - Are You Leading Through the Crisis… or Managing the Response? (Harvard Business Review) https://hbr.org/2020/03/are-you-leading-through-the-crisis-or-managing-the-response
- 4 Behaviors That Help Leaders Manage a Crisis (Harvard Business Review) https://hbr.org/2020/04/4-behaviors-that-help-leaders-manage-a-crisis
- Leading Through a Sustained Crisis Requires a Different Approach (Harvard Business Review) https://hbr.org/2020/04/4-behaviors-that-help-leaders-manage-a-crisis?autocomplete=true
- What Crisis Leadership Really Looks Like (Harvard Business Review) https://hbr.org/2020/06/what-leading-with-optimism-really-looks-like?autocomplete=true
- Getting Things Done by David Allen
- Essentialism by Greg McKeown
- The Checklist Manifesto by Atul Gawande
- High Output Management by Andrew Grove
- Academic Leadership Day by Day by Jeffrey L. Buller
These resources share a common theme: real leadership is measured by foresight, not adrenaline.
Looking Ahead
Crises happen. Work can be unpredictable. But supervisors who live perpetually in crisis mode create a workplace defined not by urgency, but by instability.
Employees deserve clarity, direction, and the ability to plan their work with confidence. Supervisors deserve the tools and training that help them break free from cycles of overwhelm. The path out of crisis mode begins with planning, presence, and a willingness to pause long enough to think.
The question is not whether crises will arise—they will. The question is whether crisis becomes the culture, or merely a moment within it.
And that answer depends, in part, on what we choose to do next.
👉Inclusive Knowledge Solutions partners with academic libraries to build reflective, equity-driven, high-trust cultures. From leadership coaching to DEI strategy to learning design, we help librarians do their most courageous, collaborative work. Let’s connect.
Add comment
Comments